PrizePicks vs Underdog: Which is the best Daily Fantasy Sports app?

PrizePicks and Underdog are two instantly recognizable and respected names on the Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS) scene. Both boast a healthy customer base and active users across the United States of America.

Members come for the new player bonus and stay for the interesting player props, fast payment options, online security, and friendly customer care.

But which is better: PrizePicks or Underdog?

Whop’s online sports writer, Frank Monkhouse, aims to answer that question in the latest addition to his sports gambling series. He tells Whop readers which app impressed him the most in key areas, including company experience, registration, promotions, platforms, sports, markets, and more. In short, he covers everything you need to know.

If sports gambling is legal in your city and you’d rather enjoy the benefits of playing with a major sportsbook, Whop has you covered. Looking for the best welcome bonus, the most reliable bookie review, or a better understanding of the most interesting markets? 

Check Frank’s online gambling series.

Head-to-head: PrizePicks vs Underdog

While some online reviews offer little more than promotional content, encouraging you to create an account, Whop sticks to the facts. I boast over a decade of experience writing content for and on major sports apps. If a company impresses me, I’ll sing their praises. But if I find an area where they come up short, I won’t be shy in telling you about it. 

Let's get to it.

Who has more experience?

When looking for a reliable, secure, and generous DFS app, experience isn’t usually the first thing you’ll focus on. Many established names in the field struggle to keep pace with the best and brightest new arrivals, and they focus on using technology to give customers excellent service.

However, I value experience and reputation highly and would like to start by looking at the backstory of both firms. 

Knowing where a business has come from often gives a clear indication of its values and hard-earned experience, keeping customers coming back for more counts for a lot in my book. Experience can’t be bought or taught.

So, which has been around longer, PrizePicks or the Underdog brand?

PrizePicks hit the scene back in 2018 and wasted no time winning favor with DFS lovers. A focus on simplicity, speed, and security encouraged players to flock to the site where they enjoy a prop-based fantasy sports experience.

The focus remains on over/under predictions for players in the top sports and leagues, including the NFL and NBA.

Underdog Fantasy isn’t quite as old as its competitor, first arriving on the DFS stage in 2020. Underdog knew it was joining an already crowded market and wanted to do things a little differently from the others.

Their Best Ball Drafts quickly gained attention, helping Underdog stand out from the crowd and attract new players. The low-maintenance approach continues to impress sports fans, especially those with a passion for the NFL.

As I said at the start of this section, experience isn’t everything when choosing a Daily Fantasy Sports app, but it shouldn’t be overlooked. PrizePicks has been around for two years longer than Underdog Fantasy, meaning they take an early lead.

A two-year head-start means PrizePicks has learned what it takes to keep their customers loyal, and their success in the industry over an extended period is no accident or fluke.

Which sportsbook offers the easiest registration?

When you’ve decided which app you wish to join and start enjoying the many benefits for DFS lovers, you’ll want hassle-free registration. There are several important steps involved in creating a DFS account using your laptop or smartphone.

You must prove your identity, age, and other information. But that shouldn’t take hours, and it shouldn’t be difficult.

Registration is another important area, and I wanted to check which business kept things simple. Was it easier to join PrizePicks or set up an account at Underdog? Let’s check.

The PrizePicks registration process is as quick and easy as you’d hope to find with the business, making it simple to gather the information they require. Visit the homepage and click the SIGN-UP button found at the top. Enter your details, including your name, date of birth, and email address. 

It’s best to register using your smartphone, as PrizePicks uses geo-location verification, keeping things quick, accurate, and smooth. You can register and start using PrizePicks in minutes.

What about Underdog Fantasy?

I’m delighted to report they also keep things clean and streamlined, with no unnecessary waiting or added checks. Download the app and click to join before completing the registration form. You must enter your name, age, and email address before verifying those details.

Underdog runs everything off a user-friendly and modern app, which you can download from the App Store or Google Play. The use of geolocation services keeps everything simple and accurate.

Both PrizePicks and Underdog Fantasy deserve credit for offering quick, secure, and simple registration. They know you want to sign up as quickly as possible and get on with enjoying the service, making predictions on your favorite sports and players.

Creating an account takes just a few minutes at both DFS apps, and you must register only once. You’ll also qualify for a generous welcome bonus, and I’ll cover that shortly.

It’s worth knowing that you will receive a request to verify your details. It may come when you first join or make a withdrawal from your Fantasy Sports account back to your payment card.

Please don’t be alarmed by this, as it’s perfectly normal and is a practice in place at all DFS sites and sports gambling apps. Verification is easy to complete on your mobile.

The easiest way to verify is to use your smartphone to snap your photo ID and email it to the customer care team. They will check the details on your passport or driver’s license to ensure they match the information on your DFS account, including your name and age.

If everything is as it should be, the customer care team will pass your account and lift any temporary restrictions.

Does PrizePicks or Underdog offer better bonuses and promotions?

The biggest and best names in the Daily Fantasy Sports arena offer all new customers a welcome bonus, which is similar to the deals you’ll find in the nation’s top sportsbooks.

Due to the competitiveness and crowded nature of the DFS market, a company knows it must stand out from the crowd to be successful. 

How does one app encourage you to join them over the competition? By luring you in with an eye-catching and generous deal, of course. But which of the two DFS apps featured in this review has the most generous bonus?

• Here are the best US sportsbook bonuses you can claim now
• Based in the UK? Here are your best bonuses

Join PrizePicks by following the steps in the previous section of my PrizePicks vs Underdog review for Whop, and you’ll instantly qualify for a stunning $50 bonus. Simply create an account, deposit, and play with $5 to release your $50 bonus.

That means for a $5 spend, you will have $55 worth of cash to play with on the app, and that’s more than enough to familiarize yourself with the many sports and markets available. 

Play smart, and you can land a handsome return using the bonus. It’s a great bonus, and I’d encourage any serious DFS player to consider grabbing their share.

Can Underdog Fantasy compete with the generosity shown by the PrizePicks marketing team? The short answer to that question is yes and then some. Join Underdog as a new customer and bank a cool 100% deposit-matched bonus up to the value of $100.

When you create an account and deposit funds, the Underdog team will match your first play up to $100. That means if you join and deposit $50, you’ll bank a $50 bonus. $75 gets you $75, and so on. To get the most from the deal, you should deposit and play $100.

It’s easy to like the offers of both PrizePicks and Underdog for different reasons.

For a $5 spend, PrizePicks will give you $55 to play with, and for a $100 spend, Underdog Fantasy will credit your account with $200. Both put you in control of how much you risk and the size of your bonus, and I’d be delighted to report that both deals are affordable. Deposit from as little as $5 to grab the bonus.

It’s difficult to pick a winner here, but I am siding with PrizePicks.

If you spend $5 there, you’ll get $50, but if you spend $5 at Underdog, you’ll get $5. There is a way you can claim both bonuses. Simply create an account and deposit at both PrizePicks and Underdog to qualify for the $50 credits and the $100. 

Regardless of which DFS app you join and collect the bonus, you must read the attached terms and conditions. I understand you’ll be keen to get on with enjoying the app and using your new customer promo credits, but taking the time to read the small print will save you effort and confusion in the future.

The more you understand how an offer works and what’s expected of you as a customer, the better your chances of using it to land a return and boost your balance.

Who has the better website and mobile app?

As a DFS player, you’re after a user-friendly, responsive, and secure platform that allows you to make predictions on your favorite players and games anytime and anywhere.

The website and app available are important factors in selecting which Daily Fantasy Sports business to join. Which offers the better platform for players: PrizePicks or Underdog Fantasy?

PrizePicks boasts an easy-to-understand and follow website and smartphone app. You can use the site on your desktop at home or play on the move with a modern smartphone app, available to download to your Android or iOS device. 

The site and app offer you access to all the same sports, markets, promotions, customer care channels, and plays. You’ll lose nothing by choosing one over the other and selecting the site or app is a matter of personal preference. Your username and password grant you access to both platforms.

Underdog is a mobile-only Daily Fantasy Sports service. That means they have a website, but it’s little more than a landing page with information on how to download the app to your handset. A recent study showed more gambling is done on smartphones than on websites and land-based sportsbooks combined. 

Underdog deserves credit for paying attention to the habits of players and keeping everything on a streamlined smartphone app. The app is fast, secure, user-friendly, modern, and super stylish. I am confident you’ll enjoy using it and will have no issues finding your way around the app, regardless of your DFS experience.

I like that Underdog Fantasy has its finger on the pulse of the DFS industry and is keeping pace with change. But I am going to score PrizePicks higher here, as I like having the option to use the website.

Yes, smartphones are easier and more convenient, but I’m a fan of the larger screens afforded by a laptop compared to a smartphone. I enjoy switching between the two platforms and using my computer when I’m studying the stats for my next play.

Which has superior sports and markets?

We now arrive at arguably the most important section of my PrizePicks vs. Underdog comparison article.

A generous welcome bonus, a user-friendly app, and a proven experience are all good, but they don’t mean much without lots of sports and markets to enjoy. After all, we join DFS apps to have our say on the most popular games and players.

Your Daily Fantasy Sports provider must give you a wealth of options, combining old favorites with the best of the new markets. Which firm stands out in this section?

PrizePicks focuses on player props across several popular sports leagues and competitions, including the NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, and college sports. You’ll never be short of an exciting game to follow. You can play over/under for individual player stats like points scored, rushing yards, or assists. 

You can also combine multiple players in one entry, similar to a parlay which is popular in sportsbook gambling. Although the sports are diverse, PrizePicks focuses on player props, which limits its appeal to DFS lovers.

Underdog Fantasy gives its customers a broader selection of DFS options and markets, such as player props and team drafts. As a member, you can play pick-em contests with over/under predictions or try your luck on the best ball drafts, which gives you a long-term interest.

You can play popular sports, including American Football, basketball, baseball, esports, and other big attractions. There’s always something to catch your eye when you access the Underdog Fantasy smartphone app.

This is another section where both parties perform well, but I love the coverage available at Underdog and have no problems picking them as the winners here.

I can see what PrizePicks is aiming for, as over/under is the major attraction for modern DFS players, but more choice means more opportunities to win. If you’re looking for great coverage, Underdog Fantasy pulls rank over PrizePicks.

Who offers secure deposit and more withdrawal options?

When playing DFS, it’s important to fund your player account quickly so you can make predictions on the next game or during the play. If you’ve landed a winner and bagged a profit, you also want to get your hands on the returns as quickly as possible.

Speed is important, but so too is security and accuracy. Do these DFS apps deliver on both fronts?

PrizePicks offers all registered members a simple range of payment methods, including credit/debit cards and e-wallets. All deposits are instant, allowing you to deposit funds and make predictions without delay. You can add $10 or more to your DFS account and withdraw your winnings at the touch of a button. 

Withdrawal times vary between instant and five working days, depending on your chosen method and location. PrizePicks offers flexibility, affordability, and security to all of its members, meaning you can play with peace of mind.

Underdog Fantasy is every bit as safe and secure as the competition, offering speedy and reliable transfers. The DFS accepts credit/debit cards, PayPal, and online banking transfers from $10 and above. As above, all deposits are instant, while withdrawals can take up to five working days to show in your account. 

Again, it depends on the method you choose and where you’re based in the country. Banking methods are convenient and user-friendly, available on your desktop or smartphone.

It would be unfair to choose one DFS over the other for fast and secure payments, as both impressed me here. They offer similar options, and all transactions are protected by the latest security measures, including Secure Socket Layer (SSL) encryption that keeps your sensitive information safe. 

Users can add several payment methods as long as they are all registered in their name and match that of the Fantasy Sports account. Adding more payment cards helps some users better manage their spending and protect their budget.

How do they compare on customer care?

When playing Daily Fantasy Sports, especially as a new customer, you want a customer care team and help section that’s honest, reliable, and responsive. Both PrizePicks and Underdog Fantasy boast respected customer care teams, but which is the best?

PrizePicks offers support through email and the help center. If you have a query, your first stop should be to the Frequently Asked Questions tab, which is a catalog of FAQs with helpful answers.

It’s perfect for troubleshooting and avoiding waiting times. Simply find the question that best suits your needs and click to expand the answer. 

If you’d prefer to speak to a member of staff, you can do so through the email channel, with issues typically answered and resolved within 24 hours.

Underdog Fantasy offers support by email, a help center, FAQs, and live chat. The last option is my favorite, as it provides the quickest resolution. Just type your question into the chat box, and a member of staff will reply as soon as possible, usually within less than three minutes, depending on the time of day and sports schedule. 

The FAQs section is ideal if you’re looking for an answer in a rush, with everything covered from registration to rules.

The presence of Live Chat means Underdog beats PrizePicks for me here. Live Chat is by far the best way to get an answer to your question from the customer care team, and I’m happy to see Underdog offer this service to its customers.

Official verdict: PrizePicks or Underdog?

As ever, I hope you enjoyed reading my article and took some useful information from this page that will make you a better, more informed player.

As is evident from reading this article, there’s very little between PrizePicks and Underdog Fantasy. They both offer a reliable, secure, and modern Daily Fantasy Sports service that brings you closer to the action and allows you to use your sporting knowledge to target a profit on the NFL, NBA, NHL, and more.

There’s not too much in it, and I wouldn’t put anyone off from joining PrizePicks or Underdog Fantasy. The best strategy could be to register an account at both firms and collect the bonuses before deciding which you prefer.

Both apps will provide you with great service.

Become a better bettor with Whop

It’s important to find the best Daily Fantasy Sports app or sportsbook gambling provider. For a sports fan and bettor, it’s like working with the best, sharpest, and most reliable tools. But making your passion for sports pay takes more than a trustworthy app.

You must fully understand how Daily Fantasy Sports and online gambling work. Then, you require a reliable strategy, the latest information, and the best predictions from professionals. 

You’ll find all that and more at Whop.

If you browse the Whop Marketplace, you’ll uncover an impressive list of sports and gambling communities, each dedicated to helping you make sharp picks and land impressive returns from your sports picks. These resources are run by tipsters, handicappers, and gambling industry experts with hard-earned industry experience and a history of finding their followers winners.

If you’re ready to elevate your game and start taking your sports predictions seriously, the Whop Marketplace is prepared and willing to guide you onto the right path. The ball is now in your court, and it’s time to step up.